This is a long one, so if you’re not interested in breastfeeding, this one probably isn’t for you! Also, I’d like to be clear that while I am a total breastfeeding advocate and feel really fortunate that it worked out for us, this isn’t a Breast is Best post looking down on anyone who formula feeds for whatever reason. It’s just my experience with it. Ok? Ok.
Welcome to my breastfeeding journey…
I read a lot about breastfeeding while I was pregnant (The La Leche League’s The Womanly Art of Breastfeeding is fantastic). I knew it was something I wanted to experience, and the list of benefits was very enticing. All the health and developmental benefits for Owen, how cost-effective it is (free!), the convenience of being able to feed anywhere, the special bond I would experience with my baby, and even weight loss for me. I was excited to experience something generations of women throughout time had experienced.
I also had no clue how to do it.
Our hospital offered a breastfeeding class, but I decided not to take it because it really seemed like it was a skill to be learned hands-on. I figured doing my own reading would leave me just as prepared as the class would, plus save me the $55 class fee! So I read up, bought some nursing bras, and hoped for the best.
Within minutes of being born, Owen was at my breast. It took a couple tries to get him on there, but with the help of my nurse he latched on and began to suck away. It was nothing like I expected it to be. It didn’t hurt, exactly, but it felt…odd. And natural, at the same time. Over our two-day hospital stay, we worked a lot on breastfeeding, he and I. But by our second morning there, I had developed a blister on each nipple and I knew from my reading that he wasn’t latched on correctly. I requested to meet with the hospital’s Lactation Consultant, but I asked at a shift change and I think my request got lost.
I kept at it, offering my breast whenever he seemed to want it and he would suck away, getting as much colostrum as he could. In the middle of the night between day three and four, my milk came in. Before I knew it, my chest was huge — fully engorged and hard as a rock. And this is where it got difficult. While Owen struggled between trying to get my milk to let down from the boulders, I struggled to learn how to guide him to the proper latch, to hold him comfortably, to know when he had enough.
On top of that, while my right breast seemed to get the message, my left was rebelling. The left side HURT. I had an aching, shooting pain throughout it and I would wince each time he latched over the not-yet-healed blisters. After every feeding I would let them air dry, then cover them with Lansinoh hoping for some relief. I also used round gel soothing pads that could be chilled in the fridge. Oh, how I loved those. (Actually, come to think of it, I think they’re still in the fridge. Right by the eggs.)
It took three weeks for the pain to subside. During that time I leaked like a faucet, waking up in drenched t-shirts and puddled sheets. Once, trying to guide him to my breast by the light of a night light in the early morning hours, I watched a stream of milk shoot across my bedroom and hit the wall. Hit.The.Wall. That’s some powerful stuff, right there. I also experienced a melt down when he had trouble gaining weight between two of his early check ups. It was recommended that I start pumping after a feeding so I would have more to offer him. I felt like a failure. I wasn’t providing enough for my baby.
In the end, I discovered that when he fell off the breast all milk-drunk after eating, instead of accepting that he was done, I had to rouse him and offer him the other breast. Most of the time, he gobbled it right up. Huh, what do you know. After that discovery, he became a weight-gaining champ. A learning process, for sure.
It was during those first three weeks — those three weeks where I was also experiencing intense baby blues and sleep deprivation — that I understood why women give up breastfeeding. Maybe some are lucky enough with their first baby to have them pop right on and nurse happily ever after, but Owen and I had a lot of learning to do together.
~
After those first few weeks, we started to get in sync. We got it. It became easier. I had worried while pregnant that I wouldn’t be able to tell when he was hungry or how I would know when he was done, but in the end, I did. I began to understand what all the fuss was about. Breastfeeding is awesome! Before I knew it, I was hooked. A total junkie. A card-holding, flag-waving, ribbon-wearing breastfeeding advocate.
I have a lot of respect for the breast. It represents so much — sexuality, power, lust, happiness, sadness, sickness, survival, life. I became obsessed and fascinated by my own body — the ability to provide exactly what my child needed, when he needed it. No questions asked.
The first time I fed him in public was at the bank. He was only a few weeks old and we had some business to attend to that would take a little while. Since they eat all the time when they’re that small, I knew I would have no choice but to do it. I was terrified. The a/c was cranking in there, but I started to sweat when I realized it was time.
I set up in an empty cubicle, draped a blanket over us, and tried to discreetly guide him to his snack. It took some gymnastics, but we got it. I’m sure it’s on a surveillance tape somewhere! But that baby step gave me confidence to keep going with feeding him on the go.
I’ve fed him everywhere. The bank, restaurants, countless parking lots sitting in the car, in the back seat of the car in the middle of an hours-long stand-still traffic jam on the Mass Pike. At a wedding, on friend’s couches, on a rooftop decking overlooking the ocean, at a handful of Starbucks, on a lawn chair in the garden department of Lowe’s. I’ve gone from using a blanket, to using nothing at all; now skilled at popping him on and off without giving anyone a free show. (Of course now, he’s at the stage where he’s distracted by everything and is known to whip his head around without warning!) I also no longer care if anyone sees anything. It’s not like I’m waving my bare breast around. I’m doing the most natural thing my body can do — feed my child.
Have I received dirty looks? You bet. And surprisingly, mostly from women around my age. But I disregard them, because hey, the baby needs to eat. Deal with it.
After a few months of regular nursing, my breasts regulated and the engorgement went down. I no longer experience a dull ache when it’s time to feed him, nor do I leak very often. (Mostly only when he sleeps longer than usual and they have to adjust to a different routine.) He’s fairly routine with his feedings, and I know when he’s going to need to eat before he gets fussy.
An additional positive to the nursing has been the weight loss. It was slow and steady, but today I weigh eight pounds less than when I became pregnant, putting me at an all-time low. A negative was a period of time where I experienced multiple episodes of clogged milk ducts, leaving me in awful pain. I spent many hours applying warm compresses, expressing milk and dislodging clogs. I can now recognize the feeling of one possibly coming on, and take a Lecithin supplement to ward it off. (It’s a vitamin used to promote a healthy heart, but it also works to keep your milk viscus and flowing easily.) I was lucky to never experience Mastitis — an infection of the breast.
I love, love, love breastfeeding. I love the time we spend together, just me and him. He’s more efficient now — not taking long to eat except for a couple solid feedings a day, but that’s ok. When he looks up at me, pats my face, or pauses to pull off, laugh and smile, my world is lit up like a Christmas tree. I hope that we can continue to nurse for a full year. He may have other ideas and wean before then, but I’d like to make it that far.
It’s been such a journey and I feel like I’ve joined the ranks. Earned my badge. And I love to talk about it. Clearly. I also like to help when I can. I had great family and friends who offered help and advice during those early days and while I try not to offer advice unsolicited, I’m always happy to answer a question if I can and be like the women who helped me.
So that’s my story. And I look forward to adding more chapters to my personal nursing story with our future children. Because breastfeeding?
ROCKS.
Do you have a breastfeeding journey to share? I’d love to hear about it.



51 comments
Comments feed for this article
January 10, 2011 at 9:22 am
Candice
Brava! I just want to stand up and cheer for you and I’m so happy for you. Good for you for nursing in public and not caring what others think and for sticking with it.
I wasn’t able to nurse b/c I had breast reduction surgery that affected my milk, I believe – although, honestly, I often think that if I had just stayed with it another day or two, my milk may have come in, maybe? I’ll never know. If I have a second, I know I’ll try harder next time.
Here’s my story:
http://www.bookishpenguin.com/blog/2010/5/19/from-breast-to-bottle-my-story.html
January 10, 2011 at 9:53 am
inmytummy
Thanks for posting this. I have never been pregnant but hope to be in the next year or so, so reading stuff like this is really helpful.
January 10, 2011 at 10:05 am
Stacey
Thanks for this post. I am expecting my first child in four months and plan to breastfeed. The whole idea is a bit overwhelming but I believe it is the best thing for my baby. May be calling on you in four short months!
January 10, 2011 at 10:25 am
Lisa
I have never understood the problem with boobs in public. And I hear people say “If you don’t like it, don’t look.” Um, if you DO like it, don’t look either. How about we all just go “ah, baby’s eating” and go on about our business?
Breastfeeding didn’t work for me (not for lack of trying), and honestly, it still makes me a bit sad to hear stories where it did. While I don’t believe that I am hurting or even depriving my child by feeding her formula, there’s a lot to be said for the convenience of the breast. The southeast is buried under snow right now, and we have to worry about heating up bottles should our power go out. Olivia was 8 weeks early, so we don’t get her out and about in public, but even if she was full term and healthy, I’m not sure we would because, good Lord, the logistics.
I’ve written about my breastfeeding journey over several posts on my blog, and also submitted it for Fearless Formula Feeder Friday. That might be a site worth checking out if you’re interested in hearing how “the other side” lives
Your post is beautifully written, and I wish every breastfeeding advocate approached it the way you do, so please don’t think I’m saying that you need to go read a formula feeders’ site. I just happen to know several people that have had really enjoyable breastfeeding experiences that still follow FFF, and I strongly believe these stories need to be seen so maybe the gap between breastfeeders and formula feeders can start to narrow. (And I think posts like yours might get discussions going and help in bridging that gap, along with helping those that breastfeed.)
January 10, 2011 at 10:31 am
Stacey
Thank you for this post! As you know, I’m always interested in hearing women’s stories about this, because no one really talks about it and it’s hard to hear both positive and negative sides of the story. My hope is that one day, it won’t be so “taboo” – either to talk about it, or to do it in public. I second what Lisa said – let’s all just say “baby’s eating” and go on about our business!
January 10, 2011 at 10:44 am
Becky
When I was first bringing James to our daycare lady, she was pregnant with her second. When she found out I was breastfeeding and using cloth diapers we instantly bonded. And we decided that it is a disservice to women that the experts tell you that it shouldn’t hurt and that it should be easy and natural from the get-go. That is true for almost no one. It was a painful, painful beginning for us too (I think a baby latching onto a blistered, cracked nipple is the definition of “toe-curling” pain), but I am so glad we stuck with it. Not just because of the financial and ease of life benefits, but also because I LOVE holding my baby close to me, seeing the joy he gets out of being able to get his dinner directly from his momma. He will be a year old at the end of February, and where once that was my final goal and I figured I would be fine weaning then, now I’m hoping to continue nursing when we are together as long as he will have me.
Good for you for sticking with it.
January 10, 2011 at 11:04 am
Veronica
9 months and counting here. I know all of the things you speak of, but I did get mastitis and it was the worse thing ever! I was so sick, for 3 days, but we pushed through it and we are still going with no end in sight. I can nurse any where any time, I don’t care who sees me, who figures out what I am doing. Most of the time when people figure out what I am doing they just smile, most women give me the “knowing” nod. I have not had any people ever give me a hard time about nursing in public. I believe that this is because breast feeding is fairly common in my neck of the woods, but I can see where in other areas of the country it isn’t so common.
I am 15 pounds below my pre-preggo weight, my baby is right on target for growth and we as a family (hubby included) are happy with the decision to give this whole breast feeding thing a try. Plus it helps that it is free – formula is so stinking expensive I don’t understand why more women don’t breast feed, just for the cost savings (minus the women who truely cannot due to health reasons)
I have a friend who is preggo now and she plans on breast feeding, my best advice to her was this “Breast feeding is a LEARNED behavior, the baby has never done it before, you have never done it before – it is hard, but if you can get through the first 3 weeks, I can promise you that you will be successful” I also believe that you can’t give yourself the option to switch to formula – I could have, there were many nights where I just hurt and didn’t want to breast feed, but I never once allowed myself to use formula, it just was not an option for me – this is because I am beyond stubborn.
Our society promotes breast feeding but it is not really supported and that just pisses me off – why is feeding a baby from the breast – its God given and evolutionary purpose – so offensive to people??? Its a boob for crying out loud, it can’t hurt you!
I am a self described Lactivist and try my best to educate people on the benefits of breast feeding and I love to support those Mammas out there who are breast feeding.
January 10, 2011 at 11:32 am
Britt
I love to read stories like this. I’ll come back to read it when I’m preggo in a few years
January 10, 2011 at 11:41 am
Kaley
Loved hearing your story, thanks for sharing. I’ll for sure be coming back to you when #2 rolls around, since I want to breastfeed longer than I did with Avalon (only made it ten weeks with a lack of milk production). I’m hoping for way more success the second time around!
January 10, 2011 at 12:24 pm
Katy
I’m sitting in the back seat of our car breast feeding as I read this post. Love it. More people need to know and understand as natural as it is to breast feed it doesn’t always go smooth from the start. We are at 2 weeks, 4 days and 20 hours (not that anyone is counting) and only now finally able to slightly see the light and the end of the cracked, bloody, engorged world we have been in. Thanks for sharing!
January 10, 2011 at 12:41 pm
CJ
Thanks for sharing this. My little one is now 8 months and I breastfed for the first 5. We decided to start him on solids at 5 months and he decided he didn’t want to nurse anymore. Not to mention that I had just started back to work so between pumping and him getting a bottle all day, it just ended. At first, I was so sad. I actually think I had a small touch of post-partum and that coupled with ending nursing made me feel like such a failure. But he is a thriving, healthy, growing baby boy which makes me feel so much better.
Breastfeeding was a hard thing for me to keep up at first because I had ZERO support from anyone except for my husband and my doctor. My MIL would actually insist that she give him a bottle instead of me nursing him. We had a huge disagreement over that. I was so stubborn, I was not going to quit.
I’m thankful though now that he had a good 5 months {well 6 technically since I still had some frozen I was able to give him another month of breastmilk} of breastmilk and I’m thankful that formula is made now to be really great for babies.
So from someone who has been there, I think its wonderful that you are going to keep at it. But also know from someone who has also seen the other side, if he decides to wean himself know that it will be ok.
Owen is at a great age, enjoy every second of it.
January 10, 2011 at 12:58 pm
LSM
I’m so glad that things are going well for you and Owen! Thanks for sharing that breastfeeding may not be an easy process at the beginning even though it’s a “natural” thing. I nursed all three of my kids and had different experiences each time. Here’s a link to the long version.
http://somewhereinthesuburbs.wordpress.com/2008/03/11/a-tale-of-three-breastfeeders/
January 10, 2011 at 1:17 pm
paula
I am glad you are breastfeeding–I think you need to learn boundaries. Plan your trips to Lowe’s when it isn’t feeding time. I have friends who love, love to breastfeed in public, they have a clear obsession with wanting to do it in public. I don’t know you, and so I am not speaking about you specifically. I also don’t want you to see anyone change their baby’s diaper on the same lawn chair that I want may to buy–and yes, I have seen this. I think it is important to realize your new found love, might not be everyone else’s new obsession.
January 10, 2011 at 1:35 pm
Molly
Hi Paula,
Life doesn’t stop when you have a baby and when they are very small as O was during that trip to Lowe’s, you don’t really have the option to schedule around feeding since feeding can be every 1.5 hours. Even if you feed before you leave the house, after you factor in driving and even a little shopping, you will have no choice but to feed again.
I’m confused about boundaries…what line was I crossing?
As far as you not wanting a chair that has been breastfed upon by comparing it to a dirty diaper, that makes me sad because it implies nursing is dirty.(also, there are loose birds flying around the garden center… that poop!)
Am I obsessed with feeding in public? Of course not. But I’m realistic and won’t compromise feeding my child because I’m not in the “ideal” spot to do so.
I appteciate your feedback though, and hope maybe this post and responses by other nursing moms might make you look at it in a different light.
January 10, 2011 at 1:31 pm
emily
Breast feeding has been wonderful for me as well! My little one is 5 months old today and we have had some obstacles but over all it has been awesome. There will always be people who disagree with it in public or some even disagree with it all together (a lot of them I have noticed are older) but it is what I feel is perfect for me and baby!! He is thriving and super healthy and no tummy issues, I feel so blessed to be able to do it whenever, where ever! I love my “hooter hider”
Good luck!
January 10, 2011 at 1:35 pm
Ivy
I think the best thing for moms expecting to breastfeed is to go into it with support and gusto, but to have no expectations. Breastfeeding was so hard for me! I have large breasts and small nipples, and that combined with a bad latcher made for the most painful five weeks of my life. We nursed for those five weeks, through cracked, sore, bleeding nipples (he would spit up pink milk, there was so much blood). I got to a point where it was affecting my relationship with my baby (a power-eater, every 90 minutes!), so I started pumping. Exclusively.
I was so determined for him to have breastmilk that I exclusively pumped for 5 1/2 months. Am I proud and glad I lasted that long? YES! Would I do it again? Probably not – I don’t think that formula is detrimental (just expensive), and oh Lord, the dishes! Washing my pump parts plus bottles seven times a day is just too much! I hate to say that I “failed” at breastfeeding, because I know I am a good mom and I have a robust, active, healthy 9 1/2 month old.
That being said, I really want to nurse my next baby for longer. So, going into it, I plan to try again, see if I can last longer than five weeks, and pray that I have a baby who latches better!
January 10, 2011 at 2:26 pm
Molly P
It’s a shame that the most natural, normal thing you can do for your baby can be frowned upon in public.
My sister-in-law was kicked out of a restaurant recently for breastfeeding. While she was not covered with a blanket, she was discreet, sat in a corner with her back turned, and we were the only customers in the joint. We decided to look up the law- and yes, it was illegal, is illegal, in most states to restrict a woman from breastfeeding. After I posted this story on facebook, a large number of people commented on how they find it offensive to see a woman nurse in public. I was even more shocked by that response, as the reason we have boobs is to feed. A baby can eat every hour an a half, sometimes even more frequently- what is a woman to do? not leave the house until the baby is one? Prudish, antiquated, and, I think, prejudicial thinking. Perhaps also predominately American thinking? as at least in Europe toplesness by the swimming pool and at the beach is the norm.
January 10, 2011 at 2:27 pm
zoey
@ paula – i get the feeling you have never nursed a baby judging from your post. it’s “feeding time” whenever the baby wants it when you are nursing. you can try to work around it as best as possible, but when the baby starts fussing, your milk lets down and you need to take care of it stat. ironic that in this country, which plasters cleavage and boobs all over the place and seems to revere that, people seem to have an issue with a mother doing exactly what they were meant for. much of the rest of the world is not so uptight.
about the lawn furniture – i would be more concerned about the people carrying head lice, bedbugs or the hair and dander and saliva from their dog or cat (or themselves) who then sit on that furniture (clearly they don’t know their boundaries?) than a nursing mother or someone changing their baby….. better keep away from movie theaters and restaurants too, in that case.
January 10, 2011 at 2:52 pm
Tara
Thank you for sharing this! I’m pregnant (due in early May) and I’m looking forward to (hopefully being able to) breastfeed when our baby arrives. I’ve been reading lots about it and it’s really nice to hear other moms’ stories. Thanks!
January 10, 2011 at 3:23 pm
Courtney
Amen! I’m right there with you, breastfeeding baby #2 and off of soy and dairy just so I can continue to do so as my babe has an intolerance. Just wanted to say that APNO is a life-saver for any blisters or nipple issues. It’s made by a compound pharmacy, so by script only–but it is a miracle thing when the other stuff (which I found) did not work. APNO = All Purpose Nipple Cream.
January 10, 2011 at 4:55 pm
emily
It does make me very sad that there would be any prejudice against feeding a baby in public. I honestly haven’t had any objections or comments, so I really didn’t think it was a big deal and I live in a very conservative, midwestern area of the country. When my little boy was first born he would eat sometimes every hour and cry so hard it would break your heart if you didn’t feed him. Also, he needed to eat often to keep up weight gain with his growth spurts. You can tell it is painful for them not to eat when their body tells them to and as a mommy I WILL NOT deprive him for the comfort of anyone else. As a mother, we do everything in our power to keep them safe from harm and a tummy ache is harm! I hope that someday things will get better, and everyone will just accept that it is part of being a parent. The same people that judge you are the people that will judge you for letting your child cry and interrupting their meal or shopping experience. I don’t want anyone to see my nipple but I also don’t want my baby to starve… that said, thank you so much for this post and from reading other mother’s posts about not being able to nurse, or only for a short time, I find myself blessed that I can do this and will not take it for granted.
January 10, 2011 at 5:30 pm
Mere
I have not had any children. But breastfeeding is fine anywhere, anytime in my book.
BUT! I have a client that I was visiting. And I sort of shocked when she pulled out a boob to feed her 9 month old (not the issue, I have boobs, you have boobs, boobs are boobs) and removed the nipple ring and put the boob in her kids mouth. UGH! I do not know why that creeped me out so bad! I totally told her while we were both laughing that the nipple ring thing was a little much for me!
It still makes me laugh! And shiver!
January 10, 2011 at 5:42 pm
Ginger
My son had breastmilk exclusively until he was one–between nursing and pumping–and even now we nurse morning and at bedtime (though I’ll be weaning him from those last two soon). And while I won’t say it was always easy (the teeth. The teeth made things…we’ll just say less than pleasant), it has been something I’m eternally grateful we were able to do. Not because I have issues with formula, but because I’m so glad we got the experience we did.
Good for you and Owen for making it work!
January 10, 2011 at 5:46 pm
Jennifer
Thank you for this post! I don’t breastfeed, I pump, and I feel like I am just about to give up. Your post has inspired to me to just keep pumping.
January 10, 2011 at 5:53 pm
Postcards
@Paula – there is a massive difference between changing a diaper in the open at a store, which I agree is unpleasant and totally unnecessary, and breastfeeding a child. I think breastfeeding is one of the best things I think a mother can do and it irritates me when people get so prudish about it – and I say that as a childless woman who currently has no plans to have children.
January 10, 2011 at 10:26 pm
beka
I loved reading this, if that isn’t totally weird. It’s so good to hear honest, real-life experiences that don’t say that it was all wonderful from the get-go.
January 11, 2011 at 12:06 am
Melissa Armstrong
It was nice to read that I am not the only one that had a rocky start. My story is here: http://adventuresofmissyandjohn.blogspot.com/2011/01/cloth-diapering-and-breastfeeding.html
Congratulations on fighting through it all and ending up with a success! Isn’t amazing what our bodies can do?
January 11, 2011 at 11:43 am
Rachel R
Thanks for sharing! It sounds like an amazing experience. With my now 13 month old daughter, I planned to breastfeed for my 12 weeks of maternity leave, and then try to pump for another month or two. It SO did not work out that way. Before I had even left the hospital (4 days with a c-section) it had been determined that my nipples were too flat for breastfeeding. THREE different lactation consultants tried and failed so I was sent home with a hospital pump. I decided to do exclusive pumping, and that worked well for 4 weeks (while my husband was home too. he would feed the bottle while i pumped for the next feeding). I definitely got soar and sick of the whole process of cleaning everything out and doing it again every 3 hours. Then my daughter started sleeping through the night and I still had to get up in the middle of the night to pump in order to keep up my supply. At 4 weeks my husband went back to work and then I was left doing the pumping and the feeding, which only left like an hour in between. My supply started to diminish dramatically, and I started having to supplement formula. By 8 weeks, I had no milk left so our daughter has been a formula-baby since then. I became a lot happier after I just switched to all formula, and since the anatomy of my nipples is not going to change, I am pretty sure that after a couple days of colostrum (sp?) for the next baby, I am going to go straight to formula after we get home from the hospital. I felt like I would have enjoyed my whole maternity leave more. I think if I were a stay-at-home mom I would try harder to make it work.
January 11, 2011 at 3:51 pm
Jennifer
Thanks for sharing. I’m the mom of a breastfeeding 8 month old and I love it. Breastfeeding is one of the best things I can do for my baby. I had a relatively easy start, with mild nipple pain for the first few weeks, but learning how to balance working and breastfeeding was very challenging. Thankfully, I got support from local Le Leche League meetings and my best advice to anyone who wants to breastfeed is to educate yourself about the benefits of breastfeeding and attend a le leche league meeting before the baby is born. And as for breastfeeding in public . . . most states, including MA and RI, have laws that allow you to breastfeed in public. Our state legislators have passed these laws because they know how important it is to be able to feed our babies!!! And in my experience, most people don’t even realize that I’m nursing. I’ve fed Pete at the supermarket, at the farmer’s market, all over Providence, going through security at the airport, trains, plains, and automobiles and if I’ve gotten dirty looks I’ve never noticed.
January 11, 2011 at 5:47 pm
Heather
Thanks for sharing your experience, Molly! It is great to hear how this aspect of motherhood has been going for you & Owen. I have a 3-month old babe and we have had an amazing experience breastfeeding too! I did experience clogged milk ducts twice (ouch!), but overall it is something I really enjoy and like you, I know better than to take it for granted. It is super convenient, yes. It helps us to bond, yes. It makes me feel good to provide something so essential for my child, yes. But I have read enough to know that it is such a difficult part of motherhood for so many others out there. I look forward to every feeding & appreciate the opportunity that I have been given to share this with my little one. It is so awe-inspiring to look down at that little face while nursing, … especially that moment when his sometimes ferocious hunger gives way to complete and utter contentedness. What love.
January 12, 2011 at 12:03 pm
paula
One thing to note Molly is how rare you see someone bottle feeding a baby at a store, restaurant or hair salon, and many babies are bottle fed formula. I think the convienance of breastfeeding, and the desire to “share your experience” with everyone is why so many woman do it in public. There are many natural and wonderful experiences that I personally do not want to share with a random stranger at Target, Lowe’s etc.
January 12, 2011 at 12:16 pm
Molly
Formula fed babies can go longer between feedings. Breast milk digests much faster and therefore the babies are hungry sooner.
I can’t speak for the friends you referenced earlier, but I don’t start my day getting excited over which public place I’m going to nurse in. As a matter of fact, I would much rather do it at home. And now that he is bigger and eats less often, 95% of the time that is the case.
What it comes down to is if the kid needs to eat, you feed them. And that’s how he eats. If you’re afraid of seeing a nipple (which you most likely won’t) turn away.
I’d rather be around a nursing mom in Target than think about putting on a shirt or even a bra (talk about a personal experience) that someone just tried on. Ick.
Agree to disagree, yes?
January 12, 2011 at 12:54 pm
lisa
In my experience, the formula digests slower thing is a myth. I believed it at first too, but I’ve never heard that from a medical professional and I know of other formula feeders that have similar feeding schedules to mine. I have a formula fed baby that eats every 2 hours during the day (at almost 4 months old) and she will cluster feed and eat hourly in the evenings during a growth spurt like a breastfed baby.
However, the reason you don’t see many bottle-fed babies out and about is because it is a royal pain to bottle feed away from home. I’ve practically been a shut in for months because it’s very hard to go anywhere when your baby has to eat every 2 hours and that requires heating up a bottle. She stays with my husband when I go out and on the rare occasions we’ve both needed to go somewhere (like Lowe’s to buy appliances), we go immediately after she eats and I still have to bring a bottle in a cooler pack and a thermos of hot water just in case it takes longer than we expect or she gets hungry earlier than usual. Luckily we’ve never had to feed her in the two times we’ve taken her out (literally, twice), but if we did, the other patrons would have to listen to her scream while we tried to heat up a bottle in a thermos of hot water or walked her out to the car.
So yeah, you don’t see bottle feeding often in public because the bottle-fed babies are at home with all of their supplies.
January 12, 2011 at 3:24 pm
lisa
P.S. I should have addressed the second paragraph @Paula. I’m trying to say that women who nurse in public don’t do it because they’re exhibitionists, they do it because baby needs to eat. ALL babies need to eat, and that can be complicated when bottle feeding, so that might be why you don’t see many bottle feeders out and about (especially with really young ones). It’s not that nursing moms WANT to share their boobs with the world.
And now I’ll shut up and stop clogging up your comments section
January 12, 2011 at 2:48 pm
Kate
@paula I see babies being bottle fed in public far more than I see babies being breastfed- I suspect it goes unnoticed, because it’s such a normal, obvious thing to be doing (as, of course, is breastfeeding). I don’t take note of mothers handing out snacks to their toddlers, and similarly, don’t really notice if they’re breast or bottle feeding their kids.
I guess that, while breastfeeding may be special, I can’t see how NOURISHING AN INFANT gets into that category of “special things we don’t do in public”, or frankly, why anyone would be remotely bothered by it.
January 12, 2011 at 12:45 pm
Keri
I have not had any children yet but personally I think it is ridiculous to put down any mother for doing what is natural and needed for her baby (at home or in public). That is why women have breasts, biologically, to BREASTfeed their young.
Know that you have a lot of support Molly and keep doing what your doing!
January 12, 2011 at 1:12 pm
Diana
I am a soon-to-be mom and I plan to breastfeed. I love hearing other peoples’ stories because it gives me the information, tips, and confidence to do it myself. I will NOT be a shut-in because I have to nurse by child. I have no problem being discreet, but I refuse to lock myself in my home because someone else might have a problem with me breastfeeding in public. Thankfully I live in small city that is very pro-breastfeeding, so I hope that I don’t have to many poor experiences when it’s my turn.
Paula, I have to say that I don’t quite understand why you think that only women who are obsessed with breastfeeding in public do it? How else do you suggest that women feed their child? I don’t mean to be rude, but it is ignorant opinions like yours that make breastfeeding in public such a negative experience for many moms.
Breastfeeding is very convenient because you don’t need a bottle, formula, water, or a way to heat the bottle while you are out. I don’t think that women should be looked down upon for breastfeeding at all, in fact they should be commended. And if I was ever asked to leave an establishment for breastfeeding, I would raise a huge stink about it.
January 12, 2011 at 1:28 pm
lisa
I fully support nursing in public, but I have to say that saying women “should be commended” for breastfeeding is a little offensive. There are many women (many more than the breastfeeding community would lead you to believe) that are unable to breastfeed. Most are very disappointed and hurt that they weren’t able to breastfeed like they had planned. They essentially spend the early months of their child’s life mourning the very first dream they had for their child, and it can be a very heartbreaking experience. Implying that a woman that is able to breastfeed should somehow be commended and raised up above mothers that formula feed isn’t very fair.
January 12, 2011 at 1:37 pm
fromasesameseed
Boy oh Boy women come in all kinds. I am an avid breastfeeding advocate and found it (and can’t wait to do it again!!!) one of the most rewarding experiences in my life.
This is repetitive but it makes me so sad and frustrated how dirty breatfeeding has become in people’s eyes. I want to shake them and ask them where our species would be without the breast? WHy are people so afraid of boobs? The babies stare at them and they are unharmed. Nearly all breatfeeding mothers are modest about it. I do agree that some hang it all out there for the point of it all, but if their actions make laws that help ME to have the right to feed my child in public then go breastfeeding “extremists”.
I disagree with Paula’s assertion that bottle fed babies are not fed often in public. At 7 months I went back to work and had to switch to formula. I very often whipped out a bottle for Shiloh. Am I suppose to have her stay home? Especially in restaurants, I just as often shook a bottle of formula as I had nursed her before in public. It’s just not as….gasp…SHOCKING so it goes unnoticed.
Bravo to you Molly and as a fellow girl who only feeds in public when necessary (and yes, it is necessary at times) I wholly support mothers who do it for any reason. It is as natural as survival.
Love, Megan
January 12, 2011 at 1:41 pm
fromasesameseed
In addition- it is equally as frustrating when mothers who formula feed (which I have done as well and will have to do again when I go back to work) become defensive when mothers who nurse are proud of it. Pride is the breast does not remotely equal judgement on the bottle. Breastfeeding is SO SO hard. Of course we are proud to pull it off. It’s nearly impossible at the beginning and to find success is something to feel pride in.
If I run a marthon must I hold in my pride because not everyone has the body type/ physical ability/ time/ schedule/ to be able to run it with me?
January 12, 2011 at 2:43 pm
lisa
I don’t disagree that breastfeeding is hard and that moms should be proud of it. It’s not the pride that I see as judgment, it’s the…judgment.
As someone whose boobs don’t work, I can tell you that if they did, I’d be damn proud. And I think you should be damn proud that your boobs work and that you stuck with breastfeeding when it got tough.
BUT. I’ve been called lazy. I’ve heard that I’m a second-rate mother, from a man (apparently his wife is 10 times the mother I am). I’ve seen multiple people talk about formula just being a bunch of chemicals, rolling their eyes at the “organic” label because how can chemicals be organic? I’ve seen blog posts saying of all the things I could feed my child, I’m feeding her the worst. I’ve had people tell me that my supply issues were my fault, that I just didn’t try hard enough. Those are the things that make me defensive.
Also bear in mind that some people might want to be proud of you, but it didn’t work out for them and they’re really hurt. It’s like if you and I were running the marathon and you finished with a PR, but I blew out my knee 3 miles in and couldn’t finish. You have every right to be proud, but it’s understandable that I’d be a little disappointed during all the celebrating since my race came to an abrupt end unexpectedly.
January 12, 2011 at 2:52 pm
fromasesameseed
Fair enough! I appreciate those feelings completely. The things directed at you were grossly unfair- and yes I have defiitely heard those opinions. I (and Molly from her post) am much more mild tempered about the whole thing. I think any extreme always fails to fairly assess the other side of things.
Nursing gets women so up in arms, huh?
Thank you for your response.
January 12, 2011 at 2:55 pm
Kate
@ Lisa: I see your point, and I KNOW (not from my own experience but from others’) how hard it is to struggle with breastfeeding in a world that’s trying to focus on “breast is best” (for GOOD reason).
But no-one HERE is judging people generally or you for not breastfeeding, they’re just congratulating Molly for having the balls to do something good that some people are uncomfortable with.
The things these other people have said to you ARE rude and unkind and, to continue the marathon anology, it would be rude and unkind to:
- brag on about [my] PR over and over and over; or
- write a blog post called “Why Those Who Don’t Finish Marathons Are Losers”
What’s not offensive is for me to post about my PR, and for my readers to congratulate me.
Lastly, big HUGS! Those haters really really suck!
January 12, 2011 at 3:15 pm
lisa
I hope that what I’m writing isn’t perceived as rude toward Molly because I also congratulate her on breastfeeding. I think this post is beautiful. She asked for breastfeeding experiences and unfortunately, mine doesn’t have a happy ending. I feel that women that weren’t able to breastfeed are often told to hush, but I felt this was a safe place to discuss all aspects – good, bad, and ugly.
January 12, 2011 at 3:19 pm
Molly
And I’m so glad you did share! I’m a fan of any mama who loves their baby, which you clearly do!
January 12, 2011 at 3:58 pm
Tammy
Hi Molly – First – I have been reading your blog for YEARS – never commented, just like to read your stories.
Since you are so open about breastfeeding, I was hoping you would answer a couple of questions. This is my 2nd pregnancy – 1st son was Breastfed for about 1 1/2 days (long story…pain and horrible nurses/lactation consultant). I really want to breastfeed my 2nd child so any advice, please offer!
1. Will you please elaborate on the pain? I mean, I know it hurts – I vividly remember the pain of the first 2 days. I want to know is, how did you get through it?
2. Did you ever feel like giving up in the beginning? Is so, how did you pass it?
3. Did you freak at all in the beginning about Owen not getting enough breastmilk, knowing your milk wasn’t all they way in yet?
Thank you for sharing your journey.
January 12, 2011 at 10:21 pm
Veronica
@Tammy
1. For me the pain only lasted a few weeks until my skin toughened up a bit, I won’t beat around the bush here – I cried every single time I breastfed for the first 2 weeks – my nipples just hurt, because they were not used to be being used! I continually worked on my baby’s latch and I used lots of lanolin, used the milk to help soothe the skin and allowed lots of air drying to occur and then magically one day it just didn’t hurt anymore (mostly due to her having mastered her latch)
2. I did want to give up, but then I told myself that it just wasn’t an option for me. My hubby and I discussed breastfeeding before hand and we decided that I would give my all, no matter what I was thinking/feeling for 2 weeks, if at that point I was done with it then I would quit. At 2 weeks baby and I were just getting into the groove of things and I pushed that “due date” to 3 weeks. At 3 weeks we were Pros!
Remember – breastfeeding is a learned behavior – your baby has never done it before and neither have you (with that baby), so you have to learn how to do it together!
3. colostrom is all they need until your milk comes in. The key is to always have the baby at your breast – Breastfeeding is a supply and demand operation – baby demands and your body will supply the milk. and when your milk comes in there is no way not to notice it.
I really got a lot on info from other moms at this website: americanpregnancy.org – join the forums, there is a whole room dedicated to breastfeeding, the ladies there are super nice and very supportive and full of ideas and knowledge to help each other out
January 13, 2011 at 8:46 am
Molly
@Tammy some great advice was offered by others before I could answer and I completely agree with them.
It took a solid three weeks for it to stop hurting for me and there were definitely times I wanted to give up. Mine was more a sharp pinching pain over the nipples and a dull ache within the left breast.
Remember: you are learning this skill together so it won’t happen overnight. Nurse often…very often. Once your milk comes in give it some time and if you feel you are struggling but are committed to bfing, seek the help of an LC for hands-on advice.
Good luck!
January 12, 2011 at 4:14 pm
Molly P
Tammy- I just want to throw out my two cents to your questions. I have a 2 year old (breastfed until 8 months) and a 6 month old (still breastfeeding). I felt like giving up every day. I FEEL like giving up every day. Then I go on. So, each day I give myself permission to quit and see how it goes, and somehow that has given me the strength not to quit. I’m not a woman who loves to breastfeed- some moments I find it rewarding, more often I don’t- perhaps that it is why it is more of a struggle for me than others. As for the third question- a baby gets plenty from the colostrum to satisfy its needs. My milk took a week to come in with my first. But, I STILL freak out about having enough milk. Whenever the baby gets fussy, I start to worry, question. I have even mixed up formula after a feeding to see if the baby would take it- and both babies always rejected it, giving me reassurance that they were not hungry, just fussy. I wish our boobs came with hourglasses so we could measure how much the baby eats. Over time you learn to trust you body. I’ve noticed that the more relaxed I am, the more faith I have in my body’s ability to provide, the more easily my milk seems to flow.
January 13, 2011 at 4:22 pm
Birdie
I’m not a mom yet, but I’m a newlywed and babies are a hot topic around here. I have to admit, reading this post made me a little (LOT) sick to my stomach. I intend to breastfeed, and I have DD breasts already. I am so absolutely terrified about the unknown world of breastfeeding from how big they’ll get (DD is already bigger than I’d like!) to how painful it will be and what if I fail? Argh lol. It never occurred to me that I’d have to face jerks that are offended by it. I’m a pretty bold, stubborn person but that seems, to me, like an unnecessary stress to be placed on a mom doing the most natural thing on earth. I know it’ll be an emotional time, and who knows what will send me over the edge? I know that you’ve been dealing with some sleep problems and I think it’s wonderful that you’ve become a champion to breastfeeding mamas. Thank you for the info and your honesty
January 22, 2011 at 4:13 am
Biberologio
Hi Molly,
I’m a mum of a two-month old little girl from Greece. I’m breastfeeding, and noone had told me it would be difficult and tiring. The worst thing was when the milk came while I was still in the maternity hospital and my breasts where suddenly huge, hard and swallen and hurt very much. A very kind nurse helped me avoid clogs by pressing and applying warm towels but it was an awful experience. I didn’t have the baby in my room as it had to be kept in the incubator for a few days. So, they gave her formula the first few days in the hospital plus all the colostrum I could get out from my breasts by pumping. BUT even so, I managed to overcome these obstacles and successfully breastfeed! I was so proud of myself and still are. My husband is very supportive and said to me that he appreciates so much what I do for our baby and while asking me to try as much as I can he totally would understand if I decided to stop, seeing that it was so painful. But this totally made me want to go on!
I applied lanolin very often at the beginning and also used silicone bpa-free nipples and the pain soon went away. I hope I can go on as much as the baby feels like easting from her mom!
Continue posting, I love reading your blog.